Sunday, August 2, 2015

Loan Originator Compensation - What to Avoid?

Prohibited Loan Originator Compensation Practices
-- Illegally Funded Employee Expense Accounts

            The CFPB’s Loan Originator Compensation Rule (“Rule”) prohibits compensation to loan originators based on the term of a loan transaction or terms of multiple transactions, but it permits compensation based on a fixed percentage of loan amount.  A compensation plan based on a fixed percentage (or basis points) of a certain loan amount may also be subject to a fixed floor or ceiling.  To attract talented loan originators or to increase production of existing originators, some mortgage lenders may attempt to introduce additional compensation mechanisms into their compensation scheme.  While some mechanisms designed to incentivize loan originators are legal, others, such as bonuses paid from individual employee expense accounts that are funded through loan-related profits resulting from origination charges or retained interest rebates, are illegal according to the CFPB.  Although the Rule does not expressly prohibit individual employee expense accounts, the CFPB has clearly shown that it believes some compensation or bonus mechanisms tied to individual employee expense accounts violate the Rule, and that they can create significant legal liability for mortgage lenders and their executives. 

1.         The CFPB’s Allegations  

In two recent enforcement actions against Franklin Loan Corporation (“Franklin”) and RPM Mortgage, Inc. (“RPM”), respectively, the CFPB targeted the lenders’ compensation plans, which allegedly contained the following features: (1) upfront commission based on a fixed percentage of the loan amount; and (2) additional compensation paid from individual employee expense accounts.  With respect to the employee expense accounts, the CFPB alleged that both Franklin and RPM: (1) established employee expense accounts for each loan originator; (2) deposited funds into the expense accounts only for closed loan with a profit; (3) the profit per loan is calculated by deducting the expenses from the revenue related to each loan; (4) the expenses related to each loan may include the loan originator’s upfront commission for the loan and/or other operating expenses allocated to the branch level; and (5) the revenue on each loan may include origination fees, net interest rebate, and other income tied to the interest rate.  The CFPB further alleged that Franklin paid quarterly bonuses to its loan originators that had positive balances in their individual employee expense accounts.  Regarding RPM, the CFPB claimed that RPM’s loan originators had open access to their individual expense accounts, and that they could use the funds to: (1) offset tolerance cures or other fee concessions to borrowers on future loans, and (2) provide periodic raises to themselves on future loans.          

2.         Civil Liability

            In the action against Franklin, the CFPB ordered Franklin to pay $730,000.00 in redress to borrowers for its alleged violation of the Rule.  Due to Franklin’s financial condition, the CFPB did not seek civil penalties against it. 

            With respect to RPM, the CFPB ordered RPM and its CEO to pay, jointly and severally, $18 million in civil damages; it also ordered RPM and its CEO to pay $1 million in civil penalties, respectively.
                                   
3.         Analysis

In both enforcement actions, the CFPB filed civil lawsuits against the defendants in federal courts in California.  The defendants in both cases chose to enter into a settlement agreement (Stipulated Final Judgment and Order) with the CFPB instead of trying the cases before the judge or a jury.  Therefore, concerned stakeholders in the mortgage industry will probably not know whether the CFPB’s allegations are facts or merely allegations.  While the results accomplished by the CFPB in these actions may demonstrate to the mortgage industry the enforcement power the CFPB wields, these cases lack the clarity and guidance that judicial decisions may otherwise provide.  Nonetheless, unless defendants in future enforcement actions are able to “fight” back, entering into settlement agreements and consent orders with the CFPB in enforcement actions will probably become the norm.   
     
            Assuming the CFPB’s allegations against Franklin and RPM were true, the “fatal” flaw in Franklin and RPM’s compensation plan was funding the employee expense accounts with revenue tied to the terms of loan transactions.  Terms under the Rule include fees, charges, interest rate, APR, collateral type, etc., related to covered mortgage loans.  By tying the employee expense accounts (e.g. source of additional compensation) to the revenue generated from each loan, Franklin and RPM’s compensation plans, arguably, incentivized loan originators to offer loan terms detrimental to consumers (higher rates and/or fees) in order to maximize the revenue on each loan so as to gain additional deposits into their expense accounts.  To be compliant, any compensation plan should not contain provisions that, directly or indirectly, purposefully or accidentally, link compensation to the terms of loan transactions.

            In zealously enforcing consumer finance protection laws, the CFPB has repeatedly demonstrated its willingness to hold mortgage company executives personally liable for civil penalties and damages.  Under the Consumer Financial Protection Act of 2010, a “related person” may be held jointly liable for a mortgage company’s violations, and the CFPB has actively relied on this legal tool to impose personal liability on executives for alleged violations that occurred on their watch.  Therefore, prudence dictates that mortgage company executives exercise due care and diligence in establishing and practicing a compliant lending culture that permeates all facets of a mortgage lender’s operations.    

4.         Conclusion

Creating a competitive and compliant loan origination compensation plan can be a challenging task.  On the one hand, the compensation plan must contain favorable terms to attract and maintain gifted loan originators in a highly competitive market place.  After all, the financial success of any mortgage lender largely depends on productive loan originators capable of originating high quality loans.  On the other hand, the Franklin and RPM enforcement actions serve as a stark reminder that a compensation plan incentivizing loan originators must comply with the Rule.  To accomplish these twin purposes in any compensation plan, mortgage lenders and their executives should carefully review their compensation plans for compliance with the Rule.  When necessary, they should engage legal counsel to see if their compensation plans contain any prohibited provisions.         

9 comments:

  1. Do you need a business loan? Our company name is zion financial services limited, we give out loans to interested customer that are seeking for loans to improve their businesses, we can assist you with a loan from €10,000 up to €15 Million euros. we offer loans at 3% interest rate. We can help you by lending you money, to start up a business or expand your existing business, we also offer personal loans, auto loans, business loans, mortgage loans, agricultural loans, or a loan for any reason etc. If you need a loan today contact us. We can lend up to 15 million euros. Email us to apply: zionloanfirm.ltd@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for sharing this post. This is very useful and informative with us. Unsecured Business loans UK for start-up gives you an opportunity to acquire funds without paper documentations and the approval comes the easy way with the broker’s guidance.

    ReplyDelete

  3. Attention!!!

    Do you have a bad credit?
    Do you need money to pay bills?
    Do you need to start up a new business?
    Do you have unfinished project at hand due to bad financing?
    Do you need money to invest in some area of specialization which will profit you? and you don’t know what to do.

    we render all kinds of loan in good services, contact us via email: inforamzanloan@gmail.com
    Thanks
    Mr . Anthony Noto
    Phone Number: +1 (712) 600 2838

    ReplyDelete
  4. Bună tuturor, sunt Patricia Sherman în Oklahoma SUA chiar acum. Aș dori să vă împărtășesc experiența mea de a împrumuta 185.000,00 USD pentru a-mi șterge proiectul bancar și a începe o afacere nouă. Totul a început când mi-am pierdut casa și mi-am luat lucrurile din cauza politicii bancare și am întâlnit niște facturi și unele nevoi personale. Așa că am devenit foarte disperat și am început să caut fonduri în toate felurile. Din fericire pentru mine, o prietenă a mea, Linda mi-a spus despre o firmă a companiei de credit, am fost intrigată de fraudă, dar am fost intrigat de situația mea și nu am avut de ales decât să primesc sfaturi de la prietenul meu despre această companie. contactarea lor chiar s-a pus la îndoială din cauza experienței mele anterioare cu creditorii online, știai asta puțin? '' Elegantloanfirm@hotmail.com Această companie a fost foarte utilă pentru mine și colegul meu și astăzi, datorită acestei companii de credit, mândrul proprietar al muncii și responsabilităților bine organizate, mi-au zâmbit. Așadar, dacă aveți nevoie cu adevărat să vă dezvoltați sau să vă începeți propria afacere sau dacă aveți nevoie cu adevărat de a împrumuta bani în orice dificultate financiară, vă recomandăm să găsiți astăzi o oportunitate de dezvoltare financiară în afacerea dvs. {E-mail:} Elegantloanfirm@hotmail.com ... online pentru creditul nu este o victimă a înșelătoriei. Mulțumesc.

    ReplyDelete
  5. real testimony and good news !!!

    My name is Mohammad, I just received my loan and has been transferred to my bank account, a few days ago I applied to the Dangote Loan Company through Lady Jane (Ladyjanealice@gmail.com), I asked Lady Jane about the Dangote Loan Company's requirements and Jane told me that if I had all the requirements that my loan would be transferred to me without delay

    And believe me now because my Rp11 billion loan with an interest rate of 2% for my Coal Mining business has just been approved and transferred to my account, this is a dream to come, I promise Lady Jane that I will tell the world is this true? and I will tell the world now because this is true

    You do not need to pay registration fees, license fees, comply with the Dangote Loan Company and you will get your loan

    for more details contact me via email: mahammadismali234@gmail.com and contact the Dangote Loan Company for your loan now via email Dangotegrouploandepartment@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  6. Apply for a loan with NOVA GLOBAL FINANCE at 3% interest Rate

    Whether you want to give your lifestyle a boost or you have an unexpected expense to deal with, a Loan from NOVA GLOBAL FINANCE is the cost-effective way of making it happen.

    Nova Global Finances are flexible: you can borrow from one thousand (1,000) to 20 million euro and with a suitable repayment period range from 1 years to 30 years. We offer a comprehensive range of personal loans, business loans, home loans and debt consolidation loans that can be adapted to suit your changing needs and circumstances at 3% interest rate.

    What you get:
     Immediate access to your funds after approval 
     Competitive interest rates
     Flexible repayment terms
     The ability to pay off your loan faster (extra payments reduce the capital amount of the loan)
     Easy approval if you require additional funds
     You can apply for a loan at your own convenient place and time

    How to apply:
    Applying for a loan is quick and easy! Businesses or Individuals interested in applying for a loan with Nova Global Finances and requires more  information on HOW TO APPLY, should SEND AN EMAIL to (novaglobalfinances@gmail.com) OR contact Camilla Karlsen on whatsApp: +31642117819 for more information and oral briefings. T&C’s Apply.

    Camilla Karlsen
    Senior Loan Manager

    ReplyDelete

  7. Loan Opportunity Offered By Mr, Pedro That Save My Family From Financial Bondage

    Hello Everyone, I am Putri Adiratnaa single mom from Jakarta, I would like to share this great testimony on how I got a loan from Mr, Pedro, when we were driven out of our home when I couldn't pay my bills anymore, After being scammed by various companies online and denied a loan from my bank and some other credit union I visited. My children were taken by foster care, I was all alone in the street. The day I shamefully walked into an old school mate who introduced me to Daisy Maureen. At first I told her that I am not ready to take any risk of requesting a loan online anymore, but she assured me that I will receive my loan from them. On a second thought, due to my homelessness I had to take a trial and applied for the loan, luckily for me I received a loan of $80,000.00 from Mr, Pedro. I'm happy I took the risk and applied for the loan. My kids have been given back to me and now I own a home and a business of my own. All thanks and gratitude goes to the help of Mr, Pedro for giving me a meaning to life when I had lost all hope. If you are currently seeking loan assistance, you can contact them via: { pedroloanss@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. Do you need an urgent loan of any kind? Loans to liquidate debts or need to loan to improve your business have you been rejected by any other banks and financial institutions? Do you need a loan or a mortgage? This is the place to look, we are here to solve all your financial problems. We borrow money for the public. Need financial help with a bad credit in need of money. To pay for a commercial investment at a reasonable rate of 3%, let me use this method to inform you that we are providing reliable and helpful assistance and we will be ready to lend you. Contact us today by email: daveloganloanfirm@gmail.com Call/Text: +1(501)800-0690 And whatsapp: +1 (501) 214‑1395

    NEED A LOAN?
    Ask Me.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I live in UK London and i am a happy woman today? and i
    told my self that any lender that rescue my
    family from our poor situation, i will refer
    any person that is looking for loan to him,
    he gave me happiness to me and my family, i
    was in need of a loan of $250,000.00 to
    start my life all over as i am a single
    mother with 3 kids I met this honest and GOD
    fearing man loan lender that help me with a
    loan of $250,000.00 U.S. Dollar, he is a GOD
    fearing man, if you are in need of loan and
    you will pay back the loan please contact
    Mr. Anthony Mitchell
    via EMAIL : applicantonline3@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete